Skip to main content

Ehlen Heldman

How Can Investment Losses Actually Help Reduce Taxes?

How Can Investment Losses Actually Help Reduce Taxes?

Seeing an investment lose money isn't usually something to celebrate.

But if you have an investment that's worth less than what you paid for it, that loss may have a tax benefit if you decide to sell.

That's the basic idea behind tax-loss harvesting: intentionally realizing an investment loss so it can potentially offset investment gains and, in some circumstances, reduce other taxable income.

But there's an important distinction:

A tax loss doesn't make a bad investment good.

The goal isn't to lose money for a tax deduction. The goal is to understand whether an investment decision you are already considering could also create a tax benefit.

 

A Loss Isn't A Tax Deduction Yet

If an investment has dropped in value but you haven't sold it, you generally have an unrealized loss.

For example, suppose you purchased an investment for $40,000 and it is now worth $30,000.

You can see a $10,000 decline on your statement.

But that doesn't automatically mean you have a $10,000 capital loss you can use on your tax return.

Generally, the loss becomes a realized capital loss when you sell the investment.

That's an important distinction because people sometimes assume that an investment being down at the end of the year automatically creates a tax benefit.

It doesn't.

The tax consequence generally comes from the transaction, not simply from the investment's current value.

 

Losses Can Offset Capital Gains

The most direct way an investment loss can help is by offsetting capital gains.

Suppose you sold one investment earlier in the year for a $15,000 capital gain.

Later, you look at another investment that you purchased for $20,000 and is now worth $12,000.

If you sell that second investment and realize an $8,000 capital loss, the loss can generally offset $8,000 of your capital gains.

That leaves you with a $7,000 net capital gain rather than $15,000.

The exact tax result depends on your circumstances, including the type and timing of the gains and losses.

But the basic concept is important:

A loss in one investment can potentially reduce the taxable effect of a gain somewhere else.

That's one reason it can be useful to review your portfolio before the end of the year rather than simply looking at each investment individually.

 

What If Your Losses Are Bigger?

Sometimes your investment losses may be greater than your gains.

That doesn't necessarily mean the remaining loss disappears.

For individuals, if total net capital losses exceed capital gains, the tax rules generally allow up to $3,000 of net capital loss to be deducted against other income in a year, or $1,500 if married filing separately. Unused losses can generally be carried forward to future years until they are used.

For example, suppose you have $10,000 of capital losses and no capital gains.

You may not be able to use the entire $10,000 against your other income in the same year.

Instead, a portion may be deductible against other income, with the remaining loss generally carried forward.

That means a loss realized this year could potentially affect your taxes in future years as well.

 

The Loss Still Has To Make Financial Sense

This is where tax planning and investment planning need to work together.

You shouldn't sell an investment simply because it has gone down.

Maybe the investment is temporarily down but still fits your long-term strategy.

Maybe the decline has nothing to do with the reason you originally bought it.

Or maybe the investment no longer belongs in your portfolio.

Imagine you bought a stock because you believed it would play a long-term role in your portfolio. It has fallen 20%, but your reasons for owning it haven't changed.

Selling it only to create a tax loss could leave you out of the investment if you can't replace it appropriately.

On the other hand, suppose the investment no longer fits your goals and you were already considering selling it.

Now the tax loss may be worth considering as part of the decision.

The tax benefit doesn't create the reason to sell.

It can make an already-reasonable portfolio decision more useful.

 

You May Be Able To Reinvest

One concern people sometimes have is:

"If I sell an investment at a loss, do I have to stay out of the market?"

Not necessarily.

Depending on your investment strategy, you may be able to sell one investment and purchase a different investment that provides similar market exposure without being considered substantially identical.

But this is an area where the tax rules matter.

The wash-sale rules can disallow a loss if you sell stock or securities at a loss and, generally, buy substantially identical stock or securities within 30 days before or after the sale. The rules can also apply in certain situations involving options and purchases in an IRA or Roth IRA.

For example, suppose you sell an investment for a $5,000 loss on December 15 and buy substantially identical securities shortly afterward.

You may not be able to claim the loss when you expected to.

The rules can be more complicated than simply waiting a few days, so transactions should be reviewed carefully.

 

Look At Your Gains And Losses Together

Tax-loss harvesting works best when you look at the whole investment picture.

You may have several investments with gains and others with losses.

Suppose your portfolio includes:

  • Investment A: $12,000 unrealized gain
  • Investment B: $7,000 unrealized gain
  • Investment C: $9,000 unrealized loss

If you already want to sell Investment C because it no longer fits your strategy, the $9,000 realized loss could potentially offset some of the gains from other sales.

But you wouldn't want to make the decision based only on those three numbers.

You'd also want to consider your overall portfolio, your investment goals, your expected income, other transactions, and what you plan to do with the proceeds.

The tax picture is one piece of the analysis.

 

Year-End Isn't The Only Time To Look

Tax-loss harvesting is often discussed in November and December because investors are reviewing their year-end tax picture.

But losses can become relevant at any point during the year.

You might sell an investment in March and realize a gain.

In June, another investment may fall substantially and no longer fit your strategy.

In that situation, you don't necessarily need to wait until December to think about how the two transactions relate.

Tax planning works better when you're paying attention throughout the year.

That doesn't mean constantly trading your portfolio.

It means recognizing that investment decisions and tax decisions can overlap.

 

Don't Let Taxes Drive Your Investments

There is a natural temptation to think:

"I can save taxes by selling this investment at a loss."

But that reverses the relationship.

You shouldn't generally invest simply to create tax losses.

And you shouldn't necessarily keep an investment you no longer want simply because selling it would create a gain.

The investment decision should come first.

Then ask:

What are the tax consequences of making this decision?

That approach keeps taxes in their proper place.

They are an important part of the financial decision, but they aren't the entire reason for making it.

 

Look At The Opportunity, Not Just The Loss

An investment loss can be frustrating.

But if you're already considering changing your portfolio, a loss may create an opportunity to make that change while potentially improving your tax position.

The key is to understand what you're actually accomplishing.

You may be offsetting gains.

You may be using part of a net loss against other income.

You may be creating a loss carryforward for a future year.

Or you may simply be making a portfolio change that makes sense regardless of the tax result.

Before selling, look at the investment, the tax consequences, and the bigger financial picture together.

A tax loss isn't valuable simply because it's a loss. It's valuable when it becomes part of a thoughtful financial decision.

 

Explore Our Financial Tips

Reach out to discuss your situation

Check the background of this financial professional on FINRA's BrokerCheck
Check the background of this financial professional on FINRA's BrokerCheck