Skip to main content

Ehlen Heldman

Tax-Loss Harvesting Is A Strategy, Not A Last-Minute Decision

Tax-Loss Harvesting Is A Strategy, Not A Last-Minute Decision

Tax-loss harvesting often gets attention near the end of the year.

You may hear advice to look through your investment accounts in December and "harvest" losses before the year ends.

But good tax-loss harvesting isn't simply a December scramble.

It starts with your investment strategy and uses tax considerations to help inform decisions throughout the year.

The goal isn't to sell investments just because they're down.

It's to recognize when an investment change may make sense and understand whether realizing a loss can also benefit your tax picture.

 

Start With Your Investment Goals

Tax-loss harvesting should begin with your portfolio—not your tax return.

Ask which investments still fit your goals.

Maybe one investment has become too risky.

Maybe your portfolio has become concentrated in one company or sector.

Maybe an investment no longer fits your time horizon.

Maybe your goals have changed since you first bought it.

For example, suppose you bought an investment several years ago as part of a long-term strategy. It has since become a much larger percentage of your portfolio than you intended.

You already know you want to reduce the position.

If the investment is also currently below your purchase price, realizing the loss may create a tax-planning opportunity.

The tax benefit didn't determine the investment decision.

It became another factor worth considering.

 

Watch For Opportunities Throughout The Year

You don't have to wait until December to identify potential losses.

Investment values change every day.

Your financial circumstances change, too.

Imagine you realize a $20,000 capital gain in April after selling an investment. Later in the year, another investment you no longer want to hold has fallen substantially.

That second investment may deserve a closer look.

You don't need to wait until December to discover that you have both gains and potential losses.

Reviewing your portfolio periodically can help you identify opportunities while there is still time to make thoughtful decisions.

This is especially useful when you're already making portfolio changes for investment reasons.

 

Understand The Tax Rules Before Selling

A tax-loss strategy can backfire if you don't understand the rules surrounding the loss.

The wash-sale rules are one of the biggest examples.

Generally, if you sell stock or securities at a loss and buy substantially identical stock or securities within 30 days before or after the sale, the loss may be disallowed for current tax purposes. Certain purchases of substantially identical securities in an IRA or Roth IRA can also create wash-sale issues.

For example, you sell an investment at a $6,000 loss on December 20. You then buy substantially identical shares on January 5 because you don't want to miss a potential rebound.

The timing falls within the wash-sale window.

That can prevent you from using the $6,000 loss the way you expected.

This is one reason tax-loss harvesting should be planned rather than rushed.

 

Consider What You Will Own Next

Selling an investment creates a second decision:

What happens next?

If you sell because the investment no longer fits your strategy, you may want to replace it with something different.

But "different" doesn't necessarily mean completely unrelated.

Depending on your investment strategy, you may be able to select another investment that provides similar diversification or market exposure without being substantially identical.

That decision should be made before the sale, not after.

For example, suppose you own one fund that has declined in value but you no longer want that particular holding. If you decide in advance what role the replacement investment should play, you can make the portfolio change intentionally rather than selling first and figuring out the rest later.

The tax loss is one part of the strategy.

The portfolio still needs a destination.

 

Look At Gains And Losses Together

A loss doesn't exist in a vacuum.

Your investment accounts may contain both winners and losers.

Suppose you have already realized $30,000 of capital gains this year. You also have an investment with a $12,000 unrealized loss that you were considering selling anyway.

Realizing that loss could potentially offset some of the gains, depending on the applicable tax rules and your overall situation.

That could make the sale more tax-efficient.

But the reverse can be true, too.

If you don't have gains, the tax benefit may look different because net capital losses have limitations on how much can generally be deducted against other income in a year, with unused losses generally carried forward.

That's why the question isn't simply, "Do I have a loss?"

It's:

"How does this loss fit into everything else happening in my tax and investment picture?"

 

Don't Create Losses Just For A Tax Benefit

Tax-loss harvesting sounds appealing because it includes the word "tax."

But the tax savings should never be confused with the actual financial benefit of the investment decision.

Suppose you have an investment worth $10,000 that is currently down $2,000. If you don't want to own it anymore, selling may make sense.

But if you still believe it belongs in your long-term portfolio, selling solely to generate a $2,000 tax loss may not improve your financial situation.

You could create transaction costs, disrupt your investment strategy, or expose yourself to market movements while you're trying to determine what to buy next.

The tax benefit is not free.

It comes with a financial decision attached to it.

 

Think Beyond December 31

Year-end can be a useful checkpoint, but it shouldn't be the first time you think about tax-loss harvesting.

A better process is to review your investment portfolio throughout the year and identify:

  • Investments you no longer want to own
  • Positions that have become too large
  • Realized gains already taken during the year
  • Unrealized losses that may be relevant
  • Major changes to your financial goals
  • Upcoming cash needs

Then, as the year progresses, you can determine whether any of those factors create a meaningful tax-planning opportunity.

That gives you time to evaluate the decision instead of trying to complete everything during the final few days of the year.

 

Remember The Bigger Financial Plan

Tax-loss harvesting is only one piece of investment planning.

You also need to consider your risk level, diversification, time horizon, cash needs, retirement plans, and what you're trying to accomplish with your investments.

For example, someone approaching retirement may be more interested in reducing portfolio risk than maximizing a current-year tax benefit.

If selling a losing investment helps them reposition the portfolio while also creating a potential tax benefit, that's worth considering.

But the tax benefit isn't the reason the portfolio needs to change.

The financial goal comes first.

 

Use Losses When They Fit The Strategy

The best time to consider tax-loss harvesting isn't necessarily December.

It's when you have a legitimate reason to evaluate an investment and enough time to understand the consequences.

That might happen in March.

It might happen in July.

It might happen during an October year-end planning review.

Or it might happen because a major change in your financial situation has caused you to rethink your portfolio.

The earlier you identify the opportunity, the more time you have to evaluate the investment decision, tax impact, and replacement strategy.

 

Make It Part Of The Process

Tax-loss harvesting shouldn't feel like a last-minute attempt to make your tax return look better.

It can be part of a broader process that connects investment management and tax planning.

Review your portfolio.

Identify what has changed.

Look at your realized gains and potential losses.

Consider whether any investments should be sold for investment reasons.

Then evaluate the tax consequences before acting.

The goal isn't to manufacture losses.

It's to recognize when a loss that already exists can become useful as part of a thoughtful financial decision.

That is what makes tax-loss harvesting a strategy rather than a December scramble.

 

Related Reading: How Can Investment Losses Actually Help Reduce Tax?

Explore Our Financial Tips

Reach out to discuss your situation

Check the background of this financial professional on FINRA's BrokerCheck
Check the background of this financial professional on FINRA's BrokerCheck